
OnlyFans tax write offs work differently for a US citizen living in the UK, because every expense is tested twice. HMRC asks whether it was "wholly and exclusively" for the business. The IRS asks whether it was "ordinary and necessary". When UK tax already exceeds US tax, the UK deduction is the one that saves money, and a US-only deduction mostly just enlarges a foreign tax credit carryover.
That last point surprises most American creators in Britain. They spend hours maximising Schedule C and very little time on the UK return, which is the one that sets their actual bill. This guide shows where the two rulebooks split and what the split does to Form 1116.
Why OnlyFans tax write offs differ on each return
A UK-resident US citizen files two returns on the same profit. The UK return applies section 34 of the Income Tax (Trading and Other Income) Act 2005, which disallows any expense not incurred wholly and exclusively for the trade. The US return applies section 162 of the Internal Revenue Code, which allows ordinary and necessary business expenses. Consequently, the same receipt can be deductible in full on one return and partly or wholly disallowed on the other.
The dual-purpose trap
The UK test is stricter where a cost has a private element. In Mallalieu v Drummond, the House of Lords refused a barrister's claim for plain black court clothing because it also kept her warm and decently dressed. The US allows more apportionment. For example, a trip that is primarily for business lets you deduct the travel to get there, plus business-day costs, even with some leisure days added.
Different calendars, too
The UK tax year runs from 6 April to 5 April, while the US uses the calendar year. An expense paid in February 2027 falls in UK tax year 2026/27 but US tax year 2027. Over time this evens out, but in any single year your deductible totals will not match. Our post on why the 1099 never matches the UK tax year covers the income side of the same problem.
Common creator expenses under both systems
The table below compares how the two systems treat the costs we see most often on creator returns. It reflects UK tax year 2026/27 and US tax year 2026.
| Expense | UK (HMRC, Self Assessment) | US (IRS, Schedule C) |
|---|---|---|
| Costumes and stage outfits | Allowed for costumes used for entertaining; everyday clothing is not | Allowed only if not suitable for everyday wear |
| Everyday make-up and grooming | Generally disallowed as dual-purpose | Generally treated as personal |
| Camera, lighting, phone | Usually deducted in full when bought under the cash basis | Expensed under the $2,500 de minimis safe harbour or depreciated |
| Working from home | Flat rate of £10, £18 or £26 a month, or a share of actual costs | $5 per sq ft up to 300 sq ft, or actual costs; space used regularly and exclusively for business |
| Mixed holiday and shoot trip | Often disallowed if there is a private purpose; identifiable business costs may be apportioned | Travel deductible if the trip is primarily business |
| Platform commission | Deductible | Deductible |
Sources: GOV.UK self-employed clothing expenses, GOV.UK simplified expenses for working from home and the IRS simplified home office option. Our OnlyFans business expenses checklist covers the US categories in more depth.
The trading allowance switch
A UK creator can deduct a flat £1,000 trading allowance instead of actual expenses, but not both. It suits a creator with low costs. However, the US has no equivalent, so you still need records of actual expenses for Schedule C. Our article on the UK trading allowance for US citizens explains how it is changing from April 2027.
A worked example: the trip that only counts once
Take an illustrative creator, Jess, a US citizen living in Bristol. For simplicity we assume her UK and US years line up and use an illustrative rate of $1.27 to £1. After the platform's commission she earns £70,000 of profit before expenses. She also takes a ten-day trip to Ibiza that mixes four days of shooting with a holiday.
| Item | UK return | US return |
|---|---|---|
| Receipts after commission | £70,000 | £70,000 |
| Camera and lighting | £2,400 | £2,400 |
| Costumes | £1,200 | £1,200 |
| Home office | £312 (flat rate, £26 x 12) | £590 (150 sq ft x $5) |
| Ibiza trip, £3,000 total | £0 (dual purpose) | £2,000 (business portion) |
| Taxable profit | £66,088 | £63,810 |
What Jess actually pays
At 2026/27 rates, UK income tax on £66,088 is about £13,867 after the £12,570 personal allowance. Class 4 National Insurance adds about £2,578. On the US side, income tax before credits on roughly $81,000 of profit is around $9,000, or about £7,100, using illustrative 2026 brackets and the standard deduction.
Jess claims a foreign tax credit on Form 1116 for her UK income tax. Because the UK tax exceeds the US tax, the credit wipes out her US income tax. Therefore, the extra £2,000 Ibiza deduction saves her nothing in US tax this year. It simply leaves more unused UK tax to carry forward. Meanwhile, the stricter UK rule costs her £800 of UK tax at 40%. The UK return is where her write-offs earn real money.
What the mismatch does to Form 1116
The foreign tax credit limit under section 904 caps the credit at the US tax on your foreign-source taxable income. A US-only deduction lowers that foreign-source income, so it lowers the limit. Consequently, more UK tax goes unused.
Unused UK tax is not lost. Under section 904(c), excess foreign tax can be carried back one year and forward ten years. Creator income usually goes in the general category on Form 1116. For some sole-trader businesses run from abroad, the foreign branch category is the right one, so check this before you file. The carryover matters if you later move back to the US, or earn US-source income that the UK does not tax first.
Social security does not change the picture
Under the US-UK totalization agreement, a self-employed US citizen resident in the UK normally pays UK Class 4 National Insurance instead of US self-employment tax, supported by a certificate of coverage. The IRS Publication 514 confirms that National Insurance paid under the agreement is not creditable. Our article on whether OnlyFans takes out taxes in the UK covers the certificate.
Five rules we apply to dual-filing creators
- Optimise the UK return first, because it usually sets the final bill.
- Keep one expense ledger with two columns: UK-allowable and US-allowable.
- Write a short business-purpose note for every trip, listing shoot days.
- Track foreign tax credit carryovers year by year; they expire after ten years.
- Re-run the comparison in the year you move countries, when the maths flips.
These rules matter most for higher-rate taxpayers. If you also hold UK investments or a pension, our UK tax for US citizens guide shows how ISAs and pensions add further mismatches.
How Tranzesta can help
We prepare both returns from a single set of books, so every expense is tested under both rules at once and the Form 1116 carryover schedule stays accurate. If your accountant only sees one side, you are probably leaving money on the other. Book a consultation and we will review your last two years of claims.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the main OnlyFans tax write offs for a US citizen in the UK?
The main OnlyFans tax write offs are platform commission, cameras and lighting, costumes not suitable for everyday wear, a share of home costs, phone and internet, and business travel. A US citizen in the UK claims them on both the UK Self Assessment return and US Schedule C, but each system applies its own test, so the allowed totals often differ.
Can I claim make-up and clothing as an OnlyFans expense?
Only in narrow cases. GOV.UK guidance allows costumes used for entertaining but not everyday clothing, and HMRC usually treats everyday make-up as dual-purpose. The IRS allows clothing only if it is unsuitable for everyday wear. Keep receipts and a note linking each item to specific content.
Why is my US Schedule C profit different from my UK profit?
The two systems use different expense tests and different tax years. HMRC requires expenses to be wholly and exclusively for the trade, while the IRS allows ordinary and necessary expenses with more apportionment. The UK year runs 6 April to 5 April and the US year is the calendar year, so the totals rarely match.
Do US deductions reduce my tax if I already claim a foreign tax credit?
Often not. When UK income tax exceeds US income tax on the same profit, Form 1116 already eliminates the US income tax. An extra US-only deduction then lowers the section 904 limit and increases the unused foreign tax carried forward, rather than reducing tax payable that year.
How long can I carry forward unused foreign tax credits?
Under section 904(c) of the Internal Revenue Code, excess foreign income taxes can be carried back one year and forward ten years. They stay in the same Form 1116 category, so UK tax on creator profit can only offset US tax on similar foreign-source income in a later year.
Can a UAE-based creator use the same foreign tax credit approach?
No. The United Arab Emirates does not levy personal income tax on individual creators, so there is no foreign income tax to credit on Form 1116. A US creator in Dubai usually relies on the foreign earned income exclusion instead, and still pays US self-employment tax because there is no US-UAE totalization agreement.
Talk to a real, signing professional
AI precision, human accountability — across the US, UK & UAE.
Book a free consultation